George Cole Auctions, NY - Read over 364 Reviews from Customers
LiveAuctioneers Logo

Bidder Reviews for George Cole Auctions (364)

badge TOP RATED
4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 364 Reviews

All Ratings
Highest Rated

Deborah
Boston, MA

Mar 25, 2024
Treasures and great service every time
Thank you, George Cole Auctions! I have been the winning bidder on dozens of items in the past 5 + years and every item is a winner and the team could not be nicer. I typically drive from Boston to pick up my winnings and have used shipping a few times. Always smooth! Look forward to auction announcements and will continue to be a regular bidder.
Report
Demi John 19"

Robert H.
Howells, NY

Mar 23, 2024
Framed W/C Winter Landsccape Sgnd D.F. Hasbrouck NY 1900 13" X 19 1/2"

David
Lima, PA

Mar 18, 2024
Buyer Beware
I purchased a set of chairs and table from this auction house in January 2024. Shortly before the auction I informed Mr Cole that I would need additional time to find a shipper if I were to be a successful bidder on any items. He then said that it was okay as long as I kept them informed of my progress. In early February a shipper that I hired arrived at their site after I had just mentioned that he would be arriving. When the shipper arrived to pick up the items George Cole refused to release them because Hughes didn't know my last name but he had my phone number and all of our text messages to show him absolute proof of ownership. The driver then left and said that he would be back. A few weeks later the driver showed back up and was informed that I had abandoned the property. I called Mr Cole and took an arrogant approach to me and said that I only had 10 days to pick the items up. If that were the case, why did he not say this when the driver first arrived to pick the items up? I have been buying oak furniture for well over 40 years and have never been treated with such disrespect as I have with this auction house. Not once had Mr Cole ever called me to have these items picked up or that they would have been considered abandoned. In my opinion this individual was not truthful to me. I am not out of money for this purchase and I feel a responsibility to the driver that has shown up twice to pick these items up. The truth of the matter is that the lot was resold at a higher price to someone else. My advice to anyone that buys from this company is that you record your conversations or get everything in writing if your circumstances differ from their policy. I would have never bought these items if I knew that Mr Cole would change the rules that we agreed upon in advance. He also claimed that he called me twice which I will emphatically state is a complete falsehood. Buyers, be aware of this company.
Report
George Cole Auctions logo
George Cole AuctionsMar 18, 2024
1). Auction Date was 1/6/24 2). 1/10/24 Our Worker Called You & Left Msg Req Info On Your Plans 3). 1/10/24 Separate Note Indicating You said "Hughes Will Pick Up This Week There was never any issue with refusing to release. Your trucker didn't come til the following month... On your invoice, and in our terms, which everyone must agree to before being able to bid, it states clearly, AND IN ALL CAPS, that..." ANY ITEMS NOT PICKED UP IN 10 DAYS WILL BE SUBJECT TO $10 PER LOT, PER DAY HANDLING FEE. ONCE THE FEES EXCEED THE PURCHASE PRICE THE ITEM IS CONSIDERED ABANDONED & WILL BE DISPOSED OF!!! "That is right there, and has been for years... So, there was never any issue with changing the rules either. Not that it matters, because the burden is on you to contact us, but we do care enough to call, and we did care enough to call, and yes we have notes from the 2 phone calls with you which can be confirmed by checking phone records. We are sorry that the outcome was dissapointing to you. Had your driver been a bit more timely with the pickup or been more communicative, we probably could have resolved this in a much more satisfactory way for you. It is regrettable that did not happen. But that is no excuse for slander and disrespect is a 2-way street sir. I am sorry you feel disrespected. I feel you have been disrespectful also and it is evidenced right here in your let's just say somewhat less than accurate recount and review. However, if you can maintain civil composure we would be happy to explore corrective action. We have been in business for almost 50 years and have found a way to make a lot tougher cookies than you to turn that frown upside down.:) 845.758.9114
Oak 4' Diam Dining Table W/ 4  Winged Griffon Ped Base W/ 3 Leaves And 6 Chairs

James
Ballston Spa, NY

Mar 10, 2024
Always a pleasure dealing with George Cole Auctions!
Always a pleasure, the staff go out of their way to make the process pleasurable and make the client feel appreciated.
Report
Folk Art Carved Wooden Eagle 12"H X 25 1/2"W

Colleen
Shohola, PA

Jan 06, 2024
Great experience!
Great service... great deals... great experience!
Report
PERSIAN, 3'3" X 10'3"

Carol
Morristown, NJ

Dec 31, 2023
Fine auction house!
Buy with confidence. Thank you! A +
Report
ROYAL COPENHAGEN BOWL W/ BIRDS 6 1/2"H X 8"W X 9"D

Jim
Yonkers, NY

Dec 23, 2023
Framed 19Th O/C Winter Landscape 11" X 14 1/2"

andrew
Feura Bush, NY

Dec 16, 2023
Excellent auction house
Amazing all around-friendly staff, great values, excellent pictures & description.
Report
19th c pine 1 drawer wash stand

Liz
Athens, NY

Oct 21, 2023
PRIM PTD CORNER CUPBOARD 7'H X 34 1/2"W

Marc
Kingston, NY

Oct 21, 2023
accuracy of descriptions
good run gallery with wide array of items
Report
SENSENIUCH BROS LITIEZ PA PROPELLER 73"

Ashley
Larchmont, NY

Oct 07, 2023
3 SECTION UPHOLS. SCREEN 7'6"H X 30"W EA SECTION

Tim
Middleburgh, NY

Sep 02, 2023
PR OAK MISSION STYLE STANDS 25"H X 21"SQ

Kenneth
New Ipswich, NH

Sep 02, 2023
Outstanding to work with
George sets the tone for the auction house that beats his name. He is ready going willing to work with the customer, and outstanding to work with. I have bid with George several times in the past and will continue to do so. He and his company make the whole experience easy and enjoyable.
Report
WALNUT CEDAR CHEST AND CONTENTS 16"H X 40"W X 9"D

Felice
New York, NY

Sep 02, 2023
Wonderful!
GreatestauctionhouseexperienceintheHudsonValley!
Report
LOT 2 PR. MEXICAN CARVED & PTD. CHAIRS

Tavan
High Falls, NY

Aug 06, 2023
High Fees
Ive dealt with this company multiple times and their on line bidding fees as well as asministrative charges are well more than most other auction houses. Make sure you're fullt aware of the added fees before bidding. My last purxhase was also in total disrepair and although their page stated it was in working order it was not. Yes, it atarted and moved but spark pkug wires and other wires were eaten by mice, the batter had been charged just enough for it to start bit after 3 days was conpletely dead etc. Just be aware.
Report
TORO TIME CUTTER ZERO TURN LAWN MOWER SS 4260

Nina
West Suffield, CT

Aug 05, 2023
TIGER MAPLE 2 PART QA STYLE HIGHBOY MADE BY HAROLD L HAYES WATERFORD CT 65-1/2"H X 26-3/4"W X

Odel
Los Angeles, CA

Aug 03, 2023
PR ARROYO CRAFTSMAN COPPER LANTERN W/SLAG GLASS PANELS 12" X 17"SQ

Kenji
Kingston, NY

Jul 09, 2023
BX FABRICS

Jake
Camillus, NY

Jul 06, 2023
2 important pieces missing entirely
I bought a lot of vintage toys including several rare and valuable items. 2 of the best pieces were plucked out of the lot before it was shipped to me. The auction house is unhelpful, condescending and degrading. There are numerous other not good reviews. Avoid in future.
Report
George Cole Auctions logo
George Cole AuctionsJul 06, 2023
There was nothing missing from this lot. From the history of the bidder we can see at least one other dispute on a surprisingly nominal item & it's over a year old w/out resolution. 1st clue we're potentially dealing w/a loose cannon. After reading an oddly worded message of accusation. We encouraged this bidder to call in, but other than another round of allegations & a statement that we will never be able to satisfy this bidder, we never heard anything else til this post. This is a bidder who's trying to get over on us and thinks that by shooting off disrespect and accusations, they could make a rucus to get a refund or discount or something, and now when that doesn't work they are throwing shade wherever they can. We have copies of the messaging, and nothing to hide. We're almost 50 yrs in the business & have conducted literally 100's of thousands of transactions. Pobody is nerfect, and we don't claim to be. But we don't take advantage of people and we dont want to be taken advantage of either. When something goes wrong we always make an effort to make it right, usually even when its not our fault. "Noisy" Accusations right from the start are an obvious sign that a buyer is trying to get over. Along with rushed timelines, instant escalation & finger pointing to distract from other possibilities w/refusal to even discuss are all signs that the buyer is not on the level. We have tight enough controls that merchandise just doesn't go missing. And the shipper has a stellar track record too. But when something goes wrong we make it right. Unless of course it is obvious we're dealing w/someone who's more interested in taking pot shots typing out slander and defamation than to give a call and actually figure something out. Over time patterns show the truth. And we're still trucking along after almost 50yrs. Please feel free to call us anytime. 845.758.9114
BX TOYS - TONKA VW BUG, JEEP, LOTS OF HOTWHEELS, RUBBER, FIGURES, ANIMALS

Howard
Belmont, MA

Jul 03, 2023
FRAMED O/B SEASCAPE SGND ROGER CURTIS 18" X 24" W/FRAME 23" X 29"

Michele
Highland, NY

Jun 10, 2023
The most professional auction house in New York
Always a pleasure dealing with George Cole Auctions
Report
CHINESE JARDENIER 12"H X 14-1/4" DIAM W/WOODEN STAND 11"H X 19" DIAM

Thom
Santa Fe, NM

May 20, 2023
TRAY 40PC DANSK DENMARK FLAMESTONE DINNER SERVICE

Linda
Tivoli, NY

May 07, 2023
LOT 2 BRONZE BANGLES

marcy t
Phoenicia, NY

May 06, 2023
excellent!!
lovely peeps, very easy transaction!!
Report
FRAMED MIRROR 64 1/2" X 17 1/2"

Frank
Rhinebeck, NY

May 06, 2023
**********
I have know George Cole for over two decades and have had several successful auction experiences. George is fair and professional along with a capable crew and they get the job done. 'Keep up the good work.
Report
TRAY 8 CHINESE BRONZE PCS. VASES 4 1/4", INCENSE BURNER 4", CANDLESTICKS 7 1/4" ETC.

Chiara
Oldsmar, FL

Mar 30, 2023
Excellent service
Excellent Service
Report
TRAY FITZ & FLOYD SWAN TEA POT & PITCHER

Maria
Newtown, CT

Mar 11, 2023
Experienced, Knowledgeable Auction House
I love dealing with this auction house, they have a great deal of experience and the knowledge that comes with it. They are easy to communicate with and very accommodating. Thank you George!!
Report
PINE COLUMN 41-3/4"H X 13-1/2" DIAM

Mar 11, 2023
TUB SILVERPLATE FLATWARE

Sheila
North Andover, MA

Feb 14, 2023
Great Company to Do Business With
George and his company were incredibly friendly and helpful to me upon my first time traveling from MA to NY to pick up my goods!! They loaded my trunk and other boxes for me without me even having to ask and with a great attitude..... will definitely be back!
Report
TUB 15 INDO SHAWLS, SCARVES -SILK, CASHMERE AND WOOL

Frank
China Grove, NC

Feb 10, 2023
STEVEN SXS SHOTGUN, 20 GA 2 3/4", DOUBLE TRIGGER, 28" BBL BUTT STOCK REPLACED WITH POLY LOOKS LIKE

Lu
Seattle, WA

Jan 17, 2023
Everything is smooth
Great auction house!
Report
TUB COSTUME JEWELRY

Aaron
Wingdale, NY

Jan 08, 2023
Great experience
Friendly quick to follow up and set a pick up date
Report
PR MAHOG GLASS TOP END STANDS 23"H X 2' SQ

Carol
Albany, NY

Dec 12, 2022
GILT FRAMED MIRROR 49-1/2" X 24"

Patricia
North Providence, RI

Dec 11, 2022
PR. INLAID CHERRY VITRINE PEDESTALS 4'H X 14"SQ

Karen
Paducah, KY

Dec 10, 2022
FRAMED CHROMOLITHOGRAPH WOMAN AND HER HORSE 17-1/2" X 14"

Gintaras
Vilnius, LT

Nov 20, 2022
LE COULTRE ATMOS CLOCK 9 1/4"H X 8 1/4"W X 6 1/4"D

Dennis
Pella, IA

Oct 16, 2022
great people skills... answers my concerns
positive to deal with
Report
VICT WALNUT WALL CABINET 32"H X 23"W X 7"D CORDTS MANSION

Amanda
Rock Hill, SC

Oct 05, 2022
Happy with item.
Trusted seller.
Report
14K RING W/ GARNETS

Kevin
Camden, SC

Sep 16, 2022
GILTWOOD & PTD. FRAMED MIRROR 41"H X 30"W

David
Ridgefield, WA

Sep 14, 2022
First but not last
My first time with this auction house but it will not be my last if lots come up of interest. Accurately described the items were exactly what I wanted. Their outside shipping should be a model for many others to follow. Zero complaints on any level and I am not pleased easily.
Report
TRAY OF 22 IVES & MARX TRAIN CARS & 2 IVES #4 ENGINES

Cindy
Columbia, SC

Sep 12, 2022
easy to work with. thank you.
thank you
Report
BLACK WILLOW NATURAL RANCH MINK FULL LENGTH COAT BY JOHN ADKINS

Chris
Leeds, GB

Aug 22, 2022
Bad service
Poor communication, took two weeks for them to repl. The item took months to arrive.
Report
George Cole Auctions logo
George Cole AuctionsAug 22, 2022
Incorrect... According to our records we were in communication with you several times... The auction closed at almost midnight on a Saturday night. We prepared sent invoices with information instructions withing 45 minutes of the close of the auction via email. Your payment was paid (by you) processed the next day (Sunday). On Monday morning we called you proactively to congratulate you on winning, thank you for bidding with us asked you if you would require shipping. We recommended a shipper you chose to bargain shop for the best rate. We advised you of the most efficient shipper, you chose a different shipper that we actually warn people against as they are known for being terribly inefficient. That was your choice once we release the item to them per your request the ball is in their court, we have no way of knowing the status. I cant say who dropped the ball, between you them, but It is unfair to put the blame on us. We go above beyond here especially with respect to proactive attempts at communication if for no other reason than we have limited time space to turn over the items reclaim the space quickly to make way for the next auction. Sorry for your experience. for the record for anyone else reading... please THINK TWICE before using the UPS Store In Kingston or Rhinecliff.
19TH C PARIAN ROCK OF AGES STATUE 18" X 11" W X 7" D

Tim
Edinboro, PA

Aug 15, 2022
We value both communicaiton and care with understanding!
We have been very pleased with our contact, communications, and responsiveness. This item was as described, services and handling of item was excellent, and working together with the local shipper to complete a smooth and professional experience. Much appreciated. Thx
Report
VIENNA COLD PTD. BRONZE ALLIGATOR W/ FETAL POSITION WOMAN INSIDE 2 1/4"H X 8"L X 3"D

Terry
San Pedro, CA

Aug 13, 2022
Items exactly as described, safe shipping!
Items exactly as described, safe shipping!
Report
TRAY 2 GERMAN STEINS SKULL W/TOP HAT 8 3/4", LINDEN LMTD 700/5000 STEIN W/SKULL LID

Nicholas
Troy, PA

Aug 08, 2022
TRAY VICT. WILCOX SILVERPLATE TEA SET

Deborah
Boston, MA

Aug 05, 2022
Two shelf bar for the win
Great addition to the corner of the dining room. Wonderful for wine and glasses on top shelf and dessert plates and servers on lower shelf. Handy and lovely to look at!
Report
MAHOG FOLDING SERVING STAND W/ 2 TRAYS 39"H X 24 1/2"W X 18"D

James
Poughkeepsie, NY

Aug 04, 2022
EMPIRE MAHOG. SETEE 34 1/2" X 47"W X 16"D

Johnny
Richmond Hill, NY

Jul 23, 2022
Quick responses, and amiable organization.
GCA are amiable and trans are swift. Highly recomendable. Would buy again. Thank you
Report
FOLDER W/ 18 AUTOG PHOTOS W/ 23 AUTOGRAPHS MICK JAGGER, CHRISTIE BRINKLEY, MEL GIBSON, PAULINA, MATT

Janet
Armonk, NY

Jul 17, 2022
Good experiences with this shop.
Items as described. Great communication and availability for pickup. Nice people.
Report
BACCARAT "BAMBOO" MOTIF VASE W/ ORIG BX

M
Rhinecliff, NY

Jul 16, 2022
LOT 3 LEAD ELF FIGURINES 3"
View:
50
TOP