Bodnar's Auction Sales, NJ - Read over 560 Reviews from Customers
LiveAuctioneers Logo

Bidder Reviews for Bodnar's Auction Sales (560)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 560 Reviews

All Ratings
Highest Rated

Michael
Locust Valley, NY

Mar 28, 2024
Lot of 2 Jenna Jameson Action Figures

Stella
Sherman, CT

Mar 27, 2024
Fabulous transaction
A smooth, seamless transaction made easy with in-house shipping which was quite reasonable. I was so impressed with how professional the Set of 12 Superior Limoges Dinner Plates were packed. One could throw them across the room without breaking! The dinner plates were perfect in unused condition. A real find! Communication on shipping was also excellent.
Report
Bodnar's Auction Sales logo
Bodnar's Auction SalesMar 27, 2024
Stella, Thank you for that! Communication is our top priority! We know how frustrating it can be when you receive no information, so we aim to keep you informed every step of the way.
Set of 12 Superior Limoges Dinner Plates

Cindy
Columbia, SC

Mar 18, 2024
I very much like the art work received.
Thank you...
Report
Bodnar's Auction Sales logo
Bodnar's Auction SalesMar 27, 2024
Cindy, Thank you! So glad you like it.
Bourbon Street Circa 1964 by Glen Fortune Banse

Martin
Westport, WA

Mar 06, 2024
Good Auctionhouse, really fast shipping, unlike Mynt auctions which never ship promptly!
Way better than Mynt auctions.
Report
Bodnar's Auction Sales logo
Bodnar's Auction SalesMar 27, 2024
Martin, I am so glad. We really do try to ship as quickly as possible. Thank you!
Lot of 3 Morgan Silver Dollars

Gary
San Diego, CA

Mar 06, 2024
Reach For the Sky by Glen Fortune Banse

Lynn
Atlanta, GA

Mar 06, 2024
Great shipping
Bought two framed pictures and the wrapping and shipping were just excellent. Thank you!
Report
Lenox Vase Watercolor by Donald Werden

Joseph W
Piscataway, NJ

Feb 14, 2024
TRUST..
Bodnar's auction, one of the best auctions.. Never a problem. EXCELLENT..
Report
Mego Star Trek Aliens Cheron Figure

Eric
Chicopee, MA

Feb 03, 2024
These guys are incredible!
With most auction houses it might take you a month or more to get your items shipped, but Bodnars is the opposite... they had my jewelry items to my door in less than a week! AND they didn't price gouge me on shipping costs like all the other lame auction houses. Wish more places were like this, seriously.
Report
Lot of Sterling Jewelry

Michael
Locust Valley, NY

Jan 29, 2024
Short Box of Marvel and DC Comics

William
Hoschton, GA

Jan 25, 2024
A great auction experience!
It’s been an absolute pleasure taking part in your auction and your people have been brilliant in the they’ve responded to my various queries. I look forward to taking part in upcoming auctions again. It’s been an absolute pleasure taking part in your auction and your people have been brilliant in the they’ve responded to my various queries. I look forward to taking part in upcoming auctions again. It’s been an absolute pleasure taking part in your auction and your people have been brilliant in the they’ve responded to my various queries. I look forward to taking part in upcoming auctions again. My experience with Bodnar's was brilliant. The item description was spot on. They were quick to respond to questions, very professional, and helped to arrange affordable shipping. I couldn't be more pleased with them and highly recommend them. Thank you!
Report
Jaguar Heritage Chronograph Men's Watch

John
Madison, OH

Jan 25, 2024
Lot of 5 Vinyl Picture Disc Records

Rob
Prospect Heights, IL

Jan 25, 2024
Good to work with.
I had an issue on a shipping cost and they were quick to get back to be in order to resolve. Customer Service is so important, especially when you're dealing with various auction houses at the same time.
Report
Lot of Native American Collectibles

Jill
Studio City, CA

Jan 23, 2024
Excellent
Excellent auction house, great shipping with the Packengers
Report
Lot of 2 Native American Indian/Southwestern Art Pottery Vases

Robert
Palmdale, CA

Dec 11, 2023
Outstanding! Highly Recommend!
I won several lots in their recent auction; the experience with Bodar’s Auction was outstanding. Accurate descriptions, prompt invoicing, and excellent communications. I look forward to bidding and purchasing with them again! Bid with confidence!
Report
Lot of 15 Disney Holiday Pins

Angela
Lansing, MI

Dec 02, 2023
Received broken merchandise
I have had an AWFUL experience with the company from start to finish. First, they would not allow me to pick up my goods, and instead told me I had to use the UPS store. My goods arrived yesterday, and an item described as brand new in the box was broken and had fresh glue on it! When I contacted the company with pictures and asked them about it, Bodner was very rude to me and claimed: I will not be refunding any money! Clearly, this company cares more about money than it does customers.
Report
Lot of 4 Collector Dolls

Michael
Locust Valley, NY

Dec 02, 2023
One of my favorite auction house on the market!
Great experience watching them auctioning goods. Very entertaining. I will return every time Bodnar's has an auction.
Report
Lot of 6 Tim Burton's Bust-Ups Series 1 - Full Set plus 1

Juan de la Luz
Mexico, MX

Nov 27, 2023
Lot of 2 Board/Strategy Games

Jeffrey
Cadott, WI

Nov 25, 2023
Antique Electric Motor on Cast Iron Base

Louis
Palisades, NY

Nov 22, 2023
Great staff and very pleasant
Always happy to see them when picking up my items.
Report
Lot of 3 Novelty Radios

Joseph W
Piscataway, NJ

Nov 22, 2023
Lot of 3 Novelty Telephones

Dennis
Port Orchard, WA

Nov 10, 2023
Antique Orkin Craft Key Wind Wood and Metal Boat

Linda
Saddle Brook, NJ

Nov 10, 2023
Lot of 2 Department 56 Snow Village Items

Ginny
Tewksbury, MA

Nov 09, 2023
Lot of 4 Animated Wizard of Oz Figures

Scott
West Jordan, UT

Nov 04, 2023
Great auction house!
Item arrived in great condition and as described.
Report
Animated Wizard of Oz Wicked Witch Figure

Cindy
Columbia, SC

Nov 03, 2023
Will not purchase from them again
Very unwilling to work with the pick up and shipping process. Due to their insistence the items are to be removed immediately, the items got severely damaged in shipping. Very unhappy customer.
Report
Bodnar's Auction Sales logo
Bodnar's Auction SalesNov 03, 2023
I am so sorry you feel this way. We list in our terms as well as each and every item description our pick up days so that you know when you bid what days they are. We also offered you one extra day the following week which we don't do, but your shipper couldn't make that day either so they had to be shipped out to you. We are not a large location with unlimited storage, and do the very best we can, but I am sorry it wasn't enough.
Mlinar Lithograph

Christopher
Patchogue, NY

Oct 25, 2023
Lot of 2 Star Wars 12" Electronic Figures

Macy
Allentown, PA

Oct 23, 2023
Easy Experience
I’ve won three auctions from Bodnar’s now and never had an issue. They send out the invoice the same day so you can pay quickly. I can’t speak on shipping since I always pick up in person, but pick up in person is super easy. You just choose a time, show up, and get your stuff. Definitely will continue to purchase from them in the future!
Report
Short Box of Amazing Spider-Man Comics - 2000's-2020's

William
Costa Mesa, CA

Oct 20, 2023
Grease John Travolta Autographed Poster Print

Peter
Bradenton, FL

Oct 19, 2023
Lot of 8 Vintage Boat Flags/Pennants

Linda
Trenton, NJ

Oct 19, 2023
Great Auction House
I just bid & won Xmas Items in a recent auction. The value of what I rec'd was unexpected & stunning. All name brand items, amounting to so much more than I bid. Needless to say, I was thrilled. I also got a real good bargain another time I bid on one of their furniture items. And if you are picking up, there is someone that helps, which you rarely get. Based on my 2 experiences, I highly recommend.
Report
Lot of Christmas Items

Robert
Omaha, NE

Oct 18, 2023
Great Auction House
Great seller and great communication!!
Report
Short Box of 80's and 90's Superman Comics

Jamie
Reading, PA

Oct 07, 2023
Great Experience!
I bought a several short boxes of comics and couldn't be more satisfied. All descriptions and photos for each lot were detailed enough that there was no question what I was getting. The livestream for the auction itself was informative (and entertaining!); staff on the livestream were knowledgeable and spoke about each comic lot as it went live. Payment and scheduling for pickup were great. Pickup process was easy; the auction house provided detailed info on how to find the pickup location, and the pickup itself was fast and organized. All staff were friendly and helpful! Would definitely buy from Bodnar's again; excited for the next comic auction!
Report
Short Box of Nightwing Comics - 2000's

Joseph W
Piscataway, NJ

Oct 06, 2023
EXCELLENT Auction..
BODNAR'S Auction.. Doesn'T get much better than this..
Report
Lot of 8 Star Trek 12" Action Figures

William
Costa Mesa, CA

Oct 05, 2023
Star Wars POTF Electronic X-Wing Fighter

Tung
Greensboro, NC

Oct 05, 2023
Sideshow Militaries of Star Wars Clone Commander

Jaime
New York, NY

Sep 30, 2023
Great experience
Dealing with Bodnar's Auction Sales is an extremely enjoyable experience, from the bidding to the shipping, the staff is always helpful and professional.
Report
Gentle Giant The Lord of the Rings Saruman Animaquette

Michael
Locust Valley, NY

Sep 27, 2023
Happy customer!
As all ways, another great auction experience with Bodnar's Auction. Can't wait for the next.
Report
Lot of 2 Living Dead Dolls - 13th Anniversary

Michael
Locust Valley, NY

Sep 21, 2023
Honest Auction House
Always a goodtime watching Bodnar's auction in real time. A lot of fun!
Report
Lot of 2 Buffy the Vampire Slayer Action Figure Box Sets

Alejandro
North Haledon, NJ

Sep 20, 2023
Majolica/Art Pottery Covered Egg Box on Pedestal

V
Valley Springs, CA

Sep 20, 2023
Brass double handled and footed floor vase

Paul
Saint Albans, ME

Sep 14, 2023
Great items.
Great items
Report
Lot of 5 Star Wars Action Collection Figures

Dennis
Lomita, CA

Sep 12, 2023
GAR Golden Jubilee 50th National Encampment Badge

Michael
Old Bridge, NJ

Aug 26, 2023
Great auction house
Always a pleasure to deal with. Great selection of collectibles to choose from. Smooth transactions and local pick-up are a breeze. Keep up the good work!!!
Report
Lot of 2 The Art of Marvel Studios Hardcover Books

Joe
Fort Worth, TX

Aug 24, 2023
Estee Lauder Perfume Compact - Dancing Bears

Patricia
Lopatcong, NJ

Aug 23, 2023
Honest Knowledgeable Friendly People
I have used Bodnar's for years. Joe and his team are honest, knowledgeable professionals, always willing to help with any questions/issues. They are genuinely friendly people who enjoy their business and helping their clients. Highly recommend them.
Report
French Satin Wood Curio

Susanlee
East Sandwich, MA

Aug 16, 2023
This auction was WOW
Excellent variety of items. Some great bargains. Everything arrived safely!
Report
Group of Sterling Silver Xavier Jewelry

Gabriel
Cheyenne, WY

Aug 14, 2023
Great Company
Great Company I will purchase from again
Report
Lot of 2 Star Wars Gentle Giant Darth Vader Helmet's

LC
Apple Valley, CA

Aug 10, 2023
Excellent packing of your items.
Excellent packing of your items.
Report
Lot of 6 Superman Action Figures

Liam
Arnold, MD

Aug 10, 2023
Very kind, very responsive and very fast and easy.
I had an amazing experience with Bodnar’s auction. They were very kind and responsive to questions and shipping was very fast and very easy. They were able to walk me through payments and kept me informed with my order. Would recommend and would love to catch another one of their auctions!
Report
Hot Toys DC Batman The Dark Knight The Joker 20 - DX11

Alejandro
North Haledon, NJ

Aug 10, 2023
Great experience.
Great experience, made the process very easy. Will definitely follow their auctions.
Report
1920's French Cylinder Desk
View:
50
TOP